Lush adaptation of Vanity Fair succeeds despite a few discordant notes
Mira Nair's adaptation of William Makepeace Thackeray's Vanity Fair generally adheres to the novel's theme and plot and even survives Nair's decision to inject a touch of modern feminism.
For those who haven't read the book or seen earlier film adaptations, Vanity Fair tells the story of Becky Sharp (Reese Witherspoon), a resourceful and ambitious young woman. An orphan reared in a boarding school, Becky first finds employment in the home of Sir Pitt Crawley (Bob Hoskins), which she runs like a well-oiled machine. But it's too lowly a position for our plucky young heroine, and she soon begins her social ascension by charming Aunt Matilda (Eileen Atkins) so that she might move in with her at her home in London and have a crack at high society. There, Becky wows the stuffed shirts she encounters with her boldness and marries Matilda's nephew Rawdon (James Purefoy), which gives her instant status. The Napoleonic Wars throw off Becky's timetable a bit and ruin her marriage, yet when she comes under the sway of the Marquess of Steyne (Gabriel Byrne), she realizes her own potential for deceit and social success.
Nair's broad canvas reflects that of Thackeray's novel. The film is a visual treat, from the ornate ballrooms and estates to the grimy London streets. She does a fine job as well keeping the film moving at a brisk pace. However, Becky seems far too modern in her attitudes, an obvious departure from the Thackeray novel. And an oddball musical sequence that would seem more at home in a Bollywood production nearly derails the film completely. That said, Witherspoon shines, giving an assured performance; like her screen counterpart, she succeeds in conquering an arena that some would think beyond her reach. Visually dynamic, and engaging throughout, Vanity Fair succeeds because Nair is able to remain truer to Thackeray's vision than to her own.
What other critics are saying. . .
Alien vs. Predator [PG-13] This pairing of 20th Century-Fox alien-creature franchises has been threatened for years, but there is no direct link to either series. Lance Henriksen stars as an industrialist who uncovers both races during an archaeological dig in Antarctica. ShowPlace West
Anaconda: The Hunt for the Blood Orchid [PG-13] This is a sequel to
the 1997 hit Anaconda, about a monster snake, but none of the principals
returned for the follow-up. An expedition searches the jungles of Borneo for
a rare orchid and uncovers a race of snakes that use the flower to gain super
strength. Parkway Pointe,
The Bourne Supremacy [PG-13] The second of the planned trilogy based on Robert Ludlum's novels about a CIA agent (Matt Damon) with a secret identity. ShowPlace West
Collateral [R] Tom Cruise is a hired killer who uses a cab to get from one hit to another; Jamie Foxx is the cab driver who slowly begins to realize what is going on. ShowPlace West, ShowPlace East
Cookout [PG-13] Todd Anderson (Quran Pender) signs a $30 million deal
with the New Jersey Nets, and in an attempt to keep himself grounded, he throws
a barbecue with comedic consequences.
Exorcist: The Beginning [R] The original movie hinted at a backstory, and this prequel details the first encounter of Father Merrin (Stellan Skarsgård) with the demon Pazuzu in Africa after World War II. ShowPlace West, ShowPlace East
Garden State [R] Zach Braff, star of the TV sitcom Scrubs, makes his directorial debut and stars in this romantic comedy about a young man who returns home for his mother's funeral and experiences many life changes. Natalie Portman co-stars. Parkway Pointe
Hero [PG-13] Zhang Yimou's award-winning and Oscar-nominated period epic stars Jet Li as an assassin who seeks revenge against the emperor who murdered his family. ShowPlace West, ShowPlace East
The Manchurian Candidate [R] Director Jonathan Demme remakes and updates the classic 1960s political thriller about a soldier (Denzel Washington) who was captured by the enemy in the Korean War (this time it's the Gulf War) and brainwashed to be used later as a pawn. Parkway Pointe
Napoleon Dynamite [PG] The title character is an odd Idaho teenager whose great loves are dancing and the ways of the ninja. Parkway Pointe
The Notebook [PG-13]Two young lovers from different backgrounds are separated when the U.S. enters World War II. Seven years later, she is engaged to a soldier when she discovers the whereabouts of her first true love.Parkway Pointe, Route 66 Drive In
Open Water [R] Two scuba divers are stranded in shark-infested waters by their tour boat.ShowPlace West, Route 66 Drive In
Paparazzi [PG-13] A celebrity decides to make an annoying photographer pay for almost causing a tragedy. ShowPlace West, ShowPlace East
The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement [G] Princess Mia (Anne Hathaway) is primed for an arranged marriage to a English suitor. Parkway Pointe, ShowPlace East, Route 66 Drive In
SuperBabies: Baby Geniuses 2 [PG] Infant brainiacs work against the clock to prevent an evil media mogul from deploying a satellite system to control people's minds. ShowPlace West
Suspect Zero [R] A cop with a rocky past hunts a mysterious serial killer. Parkway Pointe.
The Village [PG-13] A period tale about a tiny village in 1897 Pennsylvania that is surrounded by a forest hiding a group of mythical beasts. ShowPlace West
Wicker Park [PG-13] A young exec (Josh Hartnett) thinks a woman he sees in a café is a long-lost love, and puts his life on hold to trail her. ShowPlace West, ShowPlace East
Without a Paddle [PG-13] Three friends go canoeing in Washington state, hoping to find the money stolen by D.B. Cooper, who parachuted over the area in 1971. Burt Reynolds, in what must be the casting gimmick of the year, appears in a supporting role as a crazy mountain man. ShowPlace West, ShowPlace East