Johansson and Tatum shine in Fly Me to the Moon, Maxxxine and The Convert both go awry

Moon an unexpectedly delightful throwback


Greg Berlanti’s Fly Me to the Moon uses the conspiracy theory about the faked moon landing as the background for, of all things, a romantic comedy. Seems a stretch but it actually works. Thanks to a script that weaves together factual information, more than a bit of conjecture and palpable chemistry between its two charismatic leads, this breezy concoction manages to balance hearty laughs with genuine poignancy.

The clock is ticking for the United States’ space program, as the scientists and astronauts at NASA are intent on meeting President John F. Kennedy’s promise to put a man on the moon by the end of the 1960s. In addition to the science working against them, they are in danger of losing their funding.  After the tragic Apollo 1 mission that resulted in the deaths of three astronauts, the organization’s competence is questioned. Adding to their woes is changing public perception regarding the urgency of sending men into outer space. What with so many social problems plaguing the country, it’s becoming harder and harder justifying spending billions on these modern Buck Rogers.

Desperate to change this, and in the process secure further funding from Congress, government spook Moe Berkus (Woody Harrelson) hires Madison Avenue ad exec Kelly Jones (Scarlett Johansson) to turn the tide. Brought to Cape Canaveral with her assistant Ruby (Anna Garcia) in tow, she hits the ground running, proposing cross-promotional collaborations that will rekindle interest in the program as well as make the astronauts celebrities without peer.

All good ideas, yet she meets nothing but resistance from Cole Davis (Channing Tatum), a former pilot and war hero who is currently the launch director. Carrying the weight of the world on his shoulders, as well as grief over Apollo 1, he can’t be bothered with approving ad campaigns, gladhanding politicians or falling in love. And yet, despite his resistance to all three, he winds up doing each. However, things take a radical turn when Berkus tells Jones is being put in charge of staging a fake version of the moon landing that will be broadcast live if the actual mission goes sideways.

As with most rom-coms, there are more than a few misunderstandings between the couple in question.  However, there’s a bit more weight to what’s plaguing Jones. Living by the notion that the end justifies the means, she has no problem lying to get what she wants, justifying her actions as just part of the advertising game. However, she takes things too far where her personal history is concerned, her compulsive behavior ultimately revealed to be trauma-based. Johansson does a wonderful job dispensing the charm, convincing us Jones would be a force hard to resist. However, it’s during the moments in which her character lets her guard down that she shines, reminding us just how versatile she is.

Surprisingly, she and Tatum prove a compelling couple.  His exasperation in the face of her relentlessness generates constant comic tension, while he gets an opportunity to show his dramatic chops as well. It’s no surprise Harrelson is the film’s stealth weapon, stealing each scene he’s in with his sly approach, Cheshire cat smile and perpetual gleam in his eye.

More than anything, Moon proves to be an effective throwback to the kind of films we don’t see much anymore. There’s a sense of innocence here reminiscent of the Rock Hudson-Doris Day features, a playfulness between Johansson and Tatum that never allows things to get too heavy. And while a steady diet of movies like this would get old quickly, this retro exercise proves a welcome respite to the usual overblown Hollywood fare.  In theaters.

West woefully consistent with Maxxxine

As a fan of the horror genre, I’ve been waiting for the moment of revelation when I would become a fan of Ti West. The writer/director has a devout following, his supporters mentioning him in the same breath as classic genre filmmakers John Carpenter, Wes Craven and George Romero. When I hear these comparisons being made, I can’t help but wonder what they’re drinking.

His latest, Maxxxine, the final chapter of a trilogy that focuses on the pursuit of fame and its corrosive nature, didn’t change my mind. Starting with X and continuing with Pearl, both 2022, the movies are loosely tied together narratively, though the protagonists from each go to great lengths to achieve validation by any means necessary.

The time is 1985, a volatile era in which the moral majority raised their collective voices in protest over the sex and violence that had crept into pop music, as well as the explosion of the porn industry, thanks to the burgeoning home video market. This is of no concern to Maxine (Mia Goth), and in fact, she’s prospered by it.  The biggest name in adult films, she’s looking to leave the smut industry behind, hoping to break into mainstream movies. Improbably, she gets her chance when she’s cast in the sequel to a cult horror film.

Unfortunately, Maxine’s good luck is short-lived. Two co-workers of hers are found brutally slain, the police assuming they are the latest victims of the Night Stalker serial killer. And while our tarnished heroine dismisses this as a coincidence, once her best friend is butchered as well, she suddenly realizes these killings are, in fact, hitting too close to home. What ensues is an investigation by two determined cops (Bobby Canavale and Michele Monaghan), intensive stalking by a skeezy private eye (Kevin Bacon) and a final reveal that is out of left field, but not in a good way.

If nothing else, you have to admire West’s consistency as he stumbles into the same traps again and again. At just a bit over 100 minutes, the film still feels long. Deliberate pacing as well as narrative repetition hobble the story, the veteran cast the only thing keeping us engaged. Bacon is having fun, knowing a broad, bad performance isn’t out of place in a meta exercise such as this, while Giancarlo Esposito as Maxine’s agent seems to be competing with him in seeing who can steal the most scenes. However, no amount of dramatic enthusiasm or commitment can overcome the ridiculous third act West saddles her and the audience with. In delivering the requisite shock ending, the ultimate identity of the villain in question comes off as desperate rather than clever.

Obviously, there’s a “been there, done that” quality to Maxxxine, which I wouldn’t mind if it were done in service of something clever or surprising. As it is, this comes off as a lazy, bloody mess that fails to solve the mystery of West’s “brilliance” for me. In theaters.

Convert wastes epic potential

There’s an occasional sense of grandeur in Lee Tamahori’s The Convert, a would-be epic set in New Zealand during the early 19th century. Filmed on location, the lush, primitive aesthetic is perhaps the film’s strongest element, the director using it to transport us to not only an era in the past but to a society that withered over time. Unfortunately, the script by Michael Bennett, Shane Danielsen and Tamahori is a laborious, frustrating construct, one that toys with weighty ideals but comes up short in terms of context.

Lay preacher Thomas Munro (Guy Pearce) has come to the British settlement of Epworth as a missionary. This is what he tells those he encounters, but it’s obvious he’s running away from his past, his career as a soldier one he wishes to put far behind him. However, fate has other plans for him when he stumbles upon a skirmish between two warring Maori tribes. Intervening, he barters for the life of Rangimai (Tioreore Ngatai-Melbourne), a fierce young woman who initially resents his intervention.

Their relationship is a tenuous one but turns when her father, a local chieftain, decrees that Munro should teach her the ways of his culture. Inexplicably, she does not resist this and comes to appreciate the finery of modern society. But the murder of her bodyguard (Duane Evans Jr.) shatters her perceptions and heightens the violence between the two tribes present in Epworth.

While this premise hasn’t been completely exhausted and continues to have merit, Tamahori and his co-writers fail to bring any vitality to it. This situation is ripe with possibilities, but little is done to provide background regarding why these two factions are at war, or a broader context as to Maori culture or history. Anchoring the film with a foundation of this sort would have increased the narrative stakes and likely made for a more engaging story as well. What with the subject matter and grand setting, the makings of an old-school epic are here. Unfortunately, the script is threadbare and incomplete, the lack of opportunities for emotional engagement ultimately making The Convert a bit of a slog. Available through Video-On-Demand.

Chuck Koplinski

Writing for Illinois Times since 1998, Chuck Koplinski is a member of the Critic's Choice Association, the Chicago Film Critics Association and a contributor to Rotten Tomatoes. He appears on WCIA-TV twice a week to review current releases and, no matter what anyone says, thinks Tom Cruise's version of The Mummy...

Illinois Times has provided readers with independent journalism for almost 50 years, from news and politics to arts and culture.

Your support will help cover the costs of editorial content published each week. Without local news organizations, we would be less informed about the issues that affect our community..

Click here to show your support for community journalism.

Got something to say?

Send a letter to the editor and we'll publish your feedback in print!

Comments (0)
Add a Comment
  • Rapunzel

    @ Hoogland Center for the Arts LRS Theatre 1

    Sun., Aug. 4, 1 & 3 p.m.